As I understand it, the reason why President Obama’s pledge to close the facility by 2010 has failed has been due to the refusal of politicians in Congress to agree to the transfer to US soil and trial there of many of the detainees, and because other countries in the world with an interest would not take them or might mistreat them. The result has been the incarceration of 166 men, some 100 of whom have been cleared for release and so who, presumably, are innocent, in a jail notorious for its isolation and harsh conditions. With no end in sight to an intolerable situation, it is unsurprising that violence erupted earlier this month and that two thirds of the inmates have resorted to a hunger strike in desperation.
As medical staff are shipped in to care for men who have been starving since February, it is likely that force-feeding is taking place to prevent any of them from dying - perhaps out of compassion, perhaps also with an awareness of the bad publicity it would bring. Meanwhile, as the crisis grows, Obama has renewed his call for Guantanamo to close, but how this can be achieved when previous attempts have failed is a mystery. After the Boston bombings, Americans are likely to be even more averse to having potential terrorists living among them now, albeit in maximum security prisons.
The welfare of these prisoners, so many of whom should never have been detained, must come first. They have families somewhere, they have feelings, and they have human rights. Let those who deserve it face trial and justice, let those who do not have their freedom, somehow. America is the land of the free, is it not? And others could help too, if they so choose.
Claire Montanaro is a spiritual teacher, channel and blogger. Loves nature and wildlife. Author of Spiritual Wisdom.]]>
I always knew intuitively that using the Guantanamo Bay naval base in Cuba as a suspected terrorist detention venue was wrong. Leave it to someone like George W. Bush - someone who had to get help stealing the 2000 election, not only from his brother Jeb (who was Governor of Florida at the time) but others in the GOP and even the U.S. Supreme Court - to allow such a facility to be built on his watch. Ponder BBC 2 Newsnight's commentary early in 2001 about how the G.W. Bush administration conducted its foreign policy - and why the use of an obscene physical gesture effectively conveyed the arrogance of the G.W. Bush administration towards the rest of the world. It should then become clear why the Guantanamo Bay detention centres were even built in the first instance.
Thank you, William. Yes, it was a tragic and inhumane decision in the first place.